Sure it’s a guilty pleasure, but you probably watched some of the top 12 American Idols nail Beatles songs and others massacre them on Idol’s Lennon/McCartney week. Here’s our breakdown of the top twelve performances.
- The Stars!
- Carly Smithson
- David Cook
- Brooke White
- Jason Castro
- Chikezie
- Amanda Overmyer
- Michael Johns
- Syesha Mercado
- Ramiele Mulubay
- David Hernandez
- David Archuleta
- Kristy Lee Cook
The Almost Famous
The Ho-hum’s
The WTF’s
Once you’ve seen all the performances feel free to rate your top performances, argue our choices, or generally discuss the show.
David Hernandez’s story about working in a pizza joint was pretty humorous given that he was a male stripper in a gay strip club right before auditioning. His performance bodes well for a quick return to the stripper pole. Most people’s pick to waltz his way to the title David Archuleta, was saved from producing the bomb of the night only by a truly horrifying Kristy Lee Cook performance. She’s going to need to go the wardrobe malfunction route pronto if she wants to hang around…
]]>< 
