Not How, But Whether

Steve Schippert speaks eloquently about the real argument that is taking place in America between those on the Left and Right, that being not one of how to defend her, but whether to do so. I have heard that some prominent milbloggers are referring to Steve’s post as the Milblogger’s Manifesto. I think it could also be referred to as the Americans For Defending America Manifesto. An excerpt is below, but you really should read it all here.

Why is the defense of this nation a political issue at all? There are those who will argue that it is the manner in which we defend ourselves that is at issue.

That, my friends, is a convoluted disingenuous sheen of reason upon the unreasonable.

A former Attorney General currently vociferously defends a mass murdering dictator deposed by our own forces. An icon of the self-loathing anti-American academic Left, Noam Chomsky, embraces Hizballah, the chief beneficiary of Iran’s terror export, and condemns the War on Terror as bigotry wrapped in fiction. A former Vice President travels to the home of fifteen 9/11 hijackers and professes that Arabs had been “indiscriminately rounded up” by America and its sitting president and held in “unforgivable” conditions.

These are not arguments of the manner in which to defend America. These are sycophantic rantings of whether to defend her. The flood of emotions in disbelieving reaction range from anger and rage to depression and grief.

We dare not rest as the most important front of the War on Terror and for the very survival of Western Civilization lies not upon the sands of distant shores, but in our own common discourse. The most important battlegrounds are around our dinner tables and in intelligent and persuasive common sense discussion among our peers, seeking the discomfort of battle and the very defense of defense rather than the comfort and unproductive endeavor of agreement among friends.

The line has been clearly drawn. Tire not. Engage.

The Hastert "In the Mix" Story
Searching For moral clarity in A Couple Of NC Cases


  1. Vero May 24, 2006
  2. steve sturm May 24, 2006
  3. Falcon05 May 25, 2006
  4. Lorie Byrd May 25, 2006
  5. cubanbob May 25, 2006
  6. Jumpinjoe May 25, 2006
  7. Sheik Yur Bouty May 25, 2006