Karl Rove, Valerie Plame, and "reasonable doubt"

OK, enough people have challenged me on my “explanation” for Karl Rove leaking Valerie Plame’s identity that I feel obligated to put it forth. Before I do, though, let me give a few disclaimers:

  1. I am not convinced that Rove actually did the leaking;
  2. I do not believe that the “outing” constituted a violation of the law;
  3. I have absolutely zero inside knowledge about the circumstances; this is all just wild speculation.

OK, with that out of the way, we now turn to a conversation between Karl Rove and Robert Novak.

“So, Karl, what’s the administration’s position on what Joe Wilson’s saying?”

“Wilson? Oh, that former ambassador who went to Africa?”

“Yeah, him. He’s saying that Cheney sent him to investigate reports Saddam was looking to buy uranium. He found nothing, but his report was whitewashed.”

“His report is classified, Bob, and I can’t discuss it. But I can tell you this — he shouldn’t be talking about it publicly, either. Fortunately, nothing he’s said publicly actually comes from his report.”

“So, you’re saying he’s telling two different stories — one in the report, and one in the press?”

“I’m not saying that, Bob — just what I’ve heard him say doesn’t violate the secrecy laws that his report is under.”

“OK, I see. Then why did Cheney send him, then?”

“I’ve done a little digging on that one, Bob, and Cheney didn’t ‘send’ him. He asked the CIA for someone to go, and someone over there put him forward, with a hard push. Maybe we shoulda looked more carefully, not trusted CIA so readily, but that’s water over the bridge.”

“So, someone at CIA backed him for the job? Do you think that was a setup?”

“Dunno, Bob. Could be, could be perfectly innocent. The person who did the pushing could have had another motive, one that’s perfectly innocent, in terms of international politics.”

“You’ve identified the pusher? What can you tell me about that?”

“Turns out Wilson’s wife works over at CIA, in the department that handles WMD issues. But she uses her maiden name, so we didn’t make the connection right away. But Wilson seemed good on paper — former ambassador to a couple African nations, had worked in the embassy in Iraq during the first Gulf War.”

“So, she could have just been trying to do her husband a favor, give his career a boost?”

“More like a resurrection. He’d been an ambassador under Clinton, and worked hard for Gore. After 2000, he was pretty much out in the cold. And how the hell would we know that the guy’d throw us under the bus like this? Christ, if I was a conspiracy nut, I’d say the whole thing was a setup from the start, by him and his wife. But if anyone oughta know how tough it is to pull off a scheme like this, it’s me.”

“Karl, are you saying you — YOU — got sandbagged?”

“Well, maybe not me personally, but us — yeah, kinda. You can’t be perfect all the time, Bob.”

“So, can I go with this?”

“I don’t see why not. Most of it’s public record, if you just know where to look. So I don’t think you’re gonna get me fired a third time.”So, there it is.

Myth busting
Air America Takes DC by storm!


  1. -S- October 21, 2005
  2. steve sturm October 21, 2005
  3. stan25 October 21, 2005
  4. Bill K October 21, 2005
  5. Steve L. October 21, 2005
  6. Steve L. October 21, 2005
  7. Steve L October 21, 2005
  8. Bill K October 21, 2005
  9. Mark October 21, 2005
  10. DUDACKATTACK!!! October 21, 2005
  11. Bill K October 21, 2005
  12. Mark October 21, 2005
  13. Mike October 21, 2005
  14. jab October 21, 2005
  15. jab October 21, 2005
  16. Woop woop October 21, 2005
  17. Woop Woop October 21, 2005
  18. Woop woop October 21, 2005
  19. Mark October 21, 2005
  20. NeilS October 21, 2005
  21. mantis October 21, 2005
  22. Wayne Smyer October 21, 2005
  23. Andrew October 21, 2005
  24. Faith+1 October 22, 2005
  25. Mark October 22, 2005
  26. ATM October 22, 2005
  27. Chris October 22, 2005
  28. ATM October 22, 2005
  29. Mark October 22, 2005
  30. Mark October 22, 2005
  31. Faith+1 October 22, 2005
  32. Bob October 22, 2005
  33. Chris October 22, 2005
  34. Moby Andrew October 22, 2005
  35. B Moe October 22, 2005
  36. Mark October 22, 2005
  37. Mark October 22, 2005
  38. Chris October 22, 2005
  39. B Moe October 23, 2005
  40. Chris October 23, 2005
  41. B Moe October 23, 2005
  42. Jay Tea October 23, 2005
  43. Mark October 23, 2005
  44. Chris October 23, 2005
  45. B Moe October 23, 2005
  46. Mark October 23, 2005
  47. Chris October 23, 2005
  48. Chris October 23, 2005
  49. Mark October 23, 2005