Some further thoughts about Muslim Americans

Yesterday, I spoke about the Muslim community of Lodi, California, and their apparent greater concern about an FBI informer who had been among them than a couple of their fellows who had allegedly joined Al Qaeda. This caused a bit of a heated discussion in the comments, including one person who wanted to know if I was next going to call for internment camps or Holy Wars.

That was flagrantly stupid, but I’ll treat it seriously to make my point. No, I’m not going to call for either of those any time soon. Further, I’ll even point out that what they did in Lodi wasn’t illegal. It’s a principle of law that you are not obliged to report crimes or wrongdoings (except in very special cases, where certain people are called “mandatory reporters”). The Muslim community of Lodi was under no legal obligation to report the alleged terrorists among them, and did not.

But I look beyond the letter of the law. Indeed, society is more than laws. What these Muslims in Lodi did was, to my way of thinking, reprehensible. And there must be consequences for their choices.

The consequence, to me, is the forfeiting of the presumption of patriotism. They are losing the good will of their fellow Americans, who more and more believe that they can trust in the common bond that unites Americans to outweigh the sense of loyalty Muslims feel towards each other when those come in conflict — regardless of what their fellow Muslims might have done.

The greatest enemies the United States faces right now are Muslim extremists. This puts American Muslims (of the non-extremist bent) in a conflict — whose side will have their sympathies? Their fellow countrymen, or those who are dishonoring and besmirching their faith?

And every time another American Muslim chooses the latter, the more they lose that presumption of patriotism. And that is not any kind of penalty or discrimination, but a simple consequence of their choice.

Not So Great Moments In Live News Coverage
Crush Story
Tags:, ,


  1. bullwinkle August 30, 2005
  2. The Bastard August 30, 2005
  3. ed August 30, 2005
  4. ed August 30, 2005
  5. The Bastard August 30, 2005
  6. bullwinkle August 30, 2005
  7. The Bastard August 30, 2005
  8. Tim McNabb August 30, 2005
  9. The Bastard August 30, 2005
  10. Tim McNabb August 30, 2005
  11. The Bastard August 30, 2005
  12. ed August 30, 2005
  13. Kristian August 30, 2005
  14. ed August 30, 2005
  15. ed August 30, 2005
  16. Zsa Zsa August 30, 2005
  17. MikeB August 30, 2005
  18. Ed August 30, 2005
  19. cro August 30, 2005
  20. The Bastard August 30, 2005
  21. Ed August 30, 2005
  22. JohnG August 30, 2005
  23. ed August 31, 2005
  24. Cutler August 31, 2005
  25. ed August 31, 2005
  26. Moon Monkey August 31, 2005
  27. Battsman August 31, 2005
  28. ed September 1, 2005
  29. Moon Monkey September 1, 2005
  30. Vivek Golikeri April 5, 2007