The consequences of the Terri Schiavo case

(Note: this will be my first, last, and only posting on the Terri Schiavo story.)

First, everyone — and I mean everyone — ought to go here and download a living will, as I have, and get it filled out and filed as soon as possible.

Secondly, I think it is critical to note that every single thing that happened in the Schiavo case happened within the letter of the law.

By law, people can refuse medical treatment such as she was receiving.
By law, they can do that directly, or through a prepared document.
By law, when a person is incompetent to make such decisions on their own behalf, and has not made prior arrangements, that power passes to their next of kin.
By law, a spouse is considered “next of kin.”
By law, in the absence of a spouse, that power passes to any adult children.
By law, in their absence, the power then — and only then — passes to the parents.
By law, Michael Schiavo was Terri Schiavo’s spouse right up until her death.
By law, Michael Schiavo had the right to order the discontinuance of her feeding tube and any other medical care.
And by law, her parents had absolutely no legal standing in that matter.

If you are appalled by the way the law worked in this case, and are convinced that the law was wrong, then you have every moral obligation to change that law. The people who make the law — the legislatures of the several states — are, in theory, accountable to the people through elections. Get your legislators to change the law.

But exactly what laws do you want changed, and how? If you think the Schiavos (correction: Schindlers — thanks, Puppet) should have been given custody of Terri, you need to change the very nature of marriage itself. You need to grant parents the right to initiate a divorce proceeding against the explicit wishes of one party and without the cooperation of the other — do you really want that to be possible? And do you really want to weaken the bonds of marriage that tie two people together?

It’s a truism in legal circles that tough cases lead to bad laws. And this is one of the toughest. Those who are calling for wholesale shakeups of some of the most fundamental components of our society today aren’t thinking things through enough. It’s one of the reasons why laws passed in regards to a single person or situation are such a bad idea.

In the end, the Terri Schiavo case might end up causing far more violence to the institution of marriage than that feared by the religious right when they were horrified at the thought of thousands of gays racing up the aisle.

And I can’t imagine anyone would want that to be their legacy.


(And no, I am STILL not taking sides on the matter. I’m simply analyzing the potential consequences of some of the proposed actions of one side.)

(Update: 5/2/05, 3:30 p.m. — I’m closing comments on this thread. It’s degenerated into petty personal bickering, and that’s EXACTLY what I was trying to avoid.)

"When in doubt, go for the fart joke"
Quote Of The Day - Exhibit For The Prosecution Edition


  1. chad April 1, 2005
  2. Just Me April 1, 2005
  3. julie April 1, 2005
  4. Rick DeMent April 1, 2005
  5. Steve L. April 1, 2005
  6. CrowScape April 1, 2005
  7. Dave A. April 1, 2005
  8. Clash City Rocker April 1, 2005
  9. BoDiddly April 1, 2005
  10. Kabuzz52 April 1, 2005
  11. ed April 1, 2005
  12. Mac Lorry April 1, 2005
  13. Just Me April 1, 2005
  14. Curtis April 1, 2005
  15. reliapundit April 1, 2005
  16. Boyd April 1, 2005
  17. Dave A. April 1, 2005
  18. John April 1, 2005
  19. DaveD April 1, 2005
  20. Lysander April 1, 2005
  21. PajamaHadin April 1, 2005
  22. DaveD April 1, 2005
  23. Dave April 1, 2005
  24. Jay April 1, 2005
  25. Pete The Elder April 1, 2005
  26. Allan Yackey April 1, 2005
  27. Sheryl L. San Jose, CA April 1, 2005
  28. julie April 1, 2005
  29. puppets April 1, 2005
  30. reliapundit April 1, 2005
  31. DavidB April 1, 2005
  32. thynam April 1, 2005
  33. Clash City Rocker April 1, 2005
  34. Paul Deignan April 1, 2005
  35. julie April 1, 2005
  36. Angie April 1, 2005
  37. Angie April 1, 2005
  38. Jimmie April 1, 2005
  39. AnonymousDrivel April 1, 2005
  40. MMM April 1, 2005
  41. julie April 1, 2005
  42. Paul Deignan April 1, 2005
  43. Paul Deignan April 1, 2005
  44. Paul Deignan April 1, 2005
  45. DavidB April 1, 2005
  46. TnTexas April 1, 2005
  47. Scott H April 1, 2005
  48. KBiel April 1, 2005
  49. Paul Deignan April 1, 2005
  50. Scott H April 1, 2005